Cruises: more harm than benefit?

2 min
Cruises at the Port of Barcelona in an archive image.
22/11/2026 - 19:06 h

BarcelonaThe cruise industry association, CLIA, is preparing with Mastercard, a global leader in electronic payments, a study on the actual spending of cruise passengers in Barcelona. This organization, with the main shipping companies, Carnival (Costa, Cunard, or Princess), Norwegian, MSC, or Royal Caribbean, wants to demonstrate that the activity, which has many critics who view it as a source of overcrowding and pollution, provides more benefits than harms.

The task consists of demonstrating that visitors who make stops of 12 hours or less in Barcelona (about 1.7 million last year) do not just cause nuisances. According to this organization, these visitors spend an average of 12.25 euros per hour of visit, above the 9.55 euros of the conventional tourist (the one who stays overnight). They have, therefore, a “higher spending intensity,” despite spending less time in the city. And they hope to reinforce this with the Mastercard study.

This is one of the tasks of Martí Sáez, the journalist whom CLIA appointed in July as director in Catalonia, to have a presence and influence where the activity takes place, instead of doing so from Madrid. Cruises contribute about three million euros daily, 70% concentrated in Barcelona; and more than 9,000 jobs, according to the association. Visitors use public services less and do not occupy housing. And shipping companies are looking to break the pattern of being pollution generators with new ships using less polluting fuels and the electrification of the docks to plug in the cruise ships when they have docked.

For all this, they want to highlight an “unbalanced” fiscal treatment. The Generalitat's budget accompanying law included an agreement by the PSC, ERC, and Comuns that almost quintuples the municipal surcharge on cruises with stops of 12 hours or less. Cruise passengers represent around 2.5% of daily visitors to the city and at their peak never exceed 7.5%, even though the neighborhood perception is that they contribute to overcrowding. In contrast, they provide 9% of the revenue from the tourist tax and the municipal surcharge, according to CLIA.

But this will grow, because the municipal surcharge will gradually increase from 5 to 24 euros per cruise passenger in 2030, while the Generalitat's portion will remain at six euros. Thus, they will go from 11 euros per short-stay cruise passenger to 30 in 2030. This will raise the revenue for the City Council from about 4.5 million to almost 24 million in 2030 if the same number of short-stay visitors is maintained, with free allocation of funds, although prioritizing housing policies.

stats