The human body has an energy limit that it cannot exceed, no matter how much it trains
A study with elite athletes quantifies for the first time the metabolic ceiling of the human body: 2.4 times the energy it consumes at rest
The human body has resistance limits, and they are not homogeneous: while some are capable of running ultramarathons without breaking a sweat, others pant after just a short sprint. Naturally, the body can be trained, and thus over time we can reach milestones that once seemed impossible. However, even so, there will always be a wall that we cannot cross, and which is determined in large part also by our genetics. In what way do training and genes exactly determine our performance? The answer has a lot to do with how we use energy. Recent studies indicate that there exists a "metabolic ceiling," a maximum of energy that the human body is capable of burning when we push it as hard as possible.
Anyone who exercises has heard at some point about the formula to calculate maximum heart rate; that is, how many times the heart beats in a number when it is going full throttle. An approximate way to measure it is to take the number 220 and subtract the age we are. With this information, for example, one can design a training session that manages to keep the heart at 60%-80% of this maximum, which is what we call aerobic exercise, of the moderate and sustained type that allows building resistance. A more intense effort, on the other hand, will require an alternative and faster way to obtain energy for the tissues that are working, such as the muscles.
This is where the concept of the metabolic ceiling comes into play, which would be what really limits how far a person is capable of going: if a car engine can only consume a specific number of liters of gasoline, there are distances it will never be able to cover, no matter how much we watch the accelerator. The problem is that this is a figure that until now we did not know how to calculate.
The limit of elite athletes
An article published in the journal Current Biology by Dr. Herman Pontzer's group, an anthropologist at Duke University, presents for the first time a possible quantification of this ceiling. According to their demonstration, during periods of sustained exercise the human body can only consume 2.4 times its basal metabolic rate (or BMR, for its acronym in English), the minimum amount of energy, measured in calories, that the body burns throughout a day at rest to maintain basic functions.
To reach this conclusion, the scientists studied fourteen elite endurance athletes, from runners to cyclists and triathlon professionals, all highly trained in their sports. They were given water to drink with markers that are eliminated through sweat, urine, and breath. By measuring them, they were able to calculate the amount of CO₂ exhaled and, from there, the number of calories they were burning in real-time during the competitions in which they participated. This is the first time this has been achieved, because this marked water was difficult to obtain until recently.
When they added up the expenditure over activity periods of between one and 52 weeks, they saw that it practically never exceeded 2.4 times the athlete's BMR. Only on a couple of occasions did it reach a maximum of 2.7. They also noticed that the volunteers saved energy by spontaneously reducing all other less essential activities, such as walking, and even unconsciously avoided consuming more calories than they could burn within the limits of their metabolic ceiling. The scientists propose that this ceiling must be specific and surely different for each animal species, but this will need to be verified.
The body also knows how to save
Some previous studies had proposed that energy expenditure can actually reach up to ten times the BMR at specific moments, because in concrete tests some athletes can burn up to nine thousand calories a day. But this would only be sustainable for short periods of time, about 24 hours at most. If intense exercise is prolonged, the body would have to start making more rational use of its energy consumption. Because if an athlete exceeds their metabolic ceiling, the additional energy they would need to remain active would likely start to come from their own tissues, for example by destroying muscle mass, and this, obviously, would be counterproductive because it would limit their ability to perform in extreme situations. That is why the organism finds a way to avoid this.
If these studies are confirmed, we could manage to calculate our metabolic ceiling with some ease. Formulas have long been known that allow obtaining an approximation of the BMR based on age, weight, and height, and many websites facilitate their use. From there, we would only need to multiply the result by 2.4. These are data that might allow athletes to better prepare for extreme tests, but they will have little interest in the day-to-day life of the rest of the population. Mind you: this study has presented the first scientific evidence of the existence of this metabolic ceiling, which means that, no matter how much a body trains, it cannot process more than a certain amount of energy, and this sets a limit on its performance.