Almost everyone wants to kick Netanyahu out, but there is no agreement on how to do it

Eisenkot explores three paths to form a government while cross-vetoes over the Arab parties, the ultra-Orthodox, and the Likud hinder an alternative

4 min
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu in the Israeli parliament.

JerusalemIsrael still does not know who will govern it. Almost two weeks after the president, Isaac Herzog, tasked Gadi Eisenkot, former army chief of staff and leader of the Yashar party, with forming a government, his mission remains far from simple: the different opposition parties share the goal of ending the Netanyahu era, but they still disagree on fundamental issues, such as the role of Arab factions and the military service of the ultra-Orthodox. Amid negotiations, cross-vetoes, and parliamentary maneuvers, Israel is once again facing the risk of a new political paralysis.

Although the latest moves in the Knesset, the Israeli Parliament, point to a shift in the balance of power favorable to Eisenkot, there are still no guarantees that it will translate into the formation of a new government. His bloc has managed to place Matan Kahana, of Yashar, at the head of the chamber, replacing Amir Ohana, one of Netanyahu’s trusted men. It has also promoted initiatives to reverse some of the outgoing executive's reforms, such as restoring the judiciary's influence in the appointment of Supreme Court magistrates and returning powers to the attorney general's office.

These specific agreements, however, do not guarantee that the parties that have supported the legislative initiatives are willing to join a government led by Eisenkot. Negotiations between potential partners continue, both through formal and informal channels, but the obstacles are numerous. One of the main ones is the role of the ultra-Orthodox parties, traditional allies of Netanyahu, whom Eisenkot and Avigdor Lieberman, leader of Yisrael Beitenu and one of the main interlocutors in the talks, are trying to attract to a new coalition. The most delicate point is the exemption from military service for students of religious schools, an especially sensitive issue in a country that has been mobilized for war for years. Incorporating these factions could demand concessions that are difficult for other potential partners of Eisenkot to accept, such as Naftali Bennett, leader of Yachad and one of the prominent figures of the opposition.

“Serious talks”

In a statement published this Friday, the former military officer confirmed that he is holding “serious conversations” with the ultra-Orthodox parties to find a formula that would allow for strengthening the army while simultaneously preserving the status of Torah students. However, Eisenkot has insisted that he will not renounce the principle of mandatory service for all citizens, which could be military, national, or civilian. Furthermore, the two ultra-Orthodox formations voted in favor of Ofir Katz, the Likud candidate for Speaker of the Knesset, a gesture that demonstrates that they still maintain ties with the Netanyahu bloc.

Despite the difficulties, the leader of Yashar took stock of the negotiations in the same statement and pointed out three possible paths to reach government, of which he only specified two: a coalition with the ultra-Orthodox parties and an executive with Netanyahu's Likud. The Israeli media immediately interpreted that the third alternative would be a minority government with the external support of the Arab parties. Eisenkot did not explicitly mention them, a significant omission at a time when Netanyahu insists on presenting the deputies of the United Arab List (Ra’am) and the Joint List as “supporters of terrorism” and a threat to Israel's national security.

This formula, however, would also run into the reservations of some of the main leaders of the opposition bloc, especially Lieberman and Bennett, who are opposed to an executive that depends on the Arab formations. The possibility of forming a unity government with the participation of Netanyahu, as the prime minister has publicly and repeatedly defended, seems, for the moment, difficult to materialize.

In a video released on November 14, Netanyahu proposed to Eisenkot to negotiate “without preconditions” and again appealed to the need to constitute a broad Jewish executive to face, above all, the Iranian threat. In this context, according to the Israeli channel Channel 13, Yashar is considering offering Likud deputies the possibility of joining a government headed by Eisenkot, but without Netanyahu and without any agreement to rotate in the presidency of the executive.

The unity proposal, however, also divides the opposition bloc. Bennett is more in favor of exploring this path and has warned that a minority government would not be a good solution. Other opposition leaders, on the other hand, have made it clear that they have no intention of participating in a unity executive with Netanyahu. In parallel, the meeting of more than two hours that the prime minister and Bennett held on Wednesday has added a new element of uncertainty.

The meeting, presented as a conversation about security issues, surprised Bennett's allies, who, according to Israeli media, had not been informed about it beforehand. Within Eisenkot's bloc, there is reportedly unease over the possibility that Bennett is exploring an alternative with Netanyahu, while his entourage denies that he has any intention of abandoning the opposition.

For now, there is no agreement. The negotiating teams plan to resume talks on Sunday, amidst mutual recriminations: the Likud accuses the Eisenkot bloc of not having a real will to reach an agreement, while Yashar asserts that he is making a “genuine effort” and denounces the distance between what the Likud says, what it does, and what it is actually willing to accept.

In this scenario of political gridlock, Eisenkot has until December 6 to try to form a government, a deadline that the president, Isaac Herzog, could extend until the 19th. If he fails, Netanyahu could have a new opportunity to form an executive. If he also fails to do so, Israel will have to return to the polls next year.

stats