The answer cannot be less democracy
-
CAT -
CAST
The November 29th campaign is explained as a simple choice. Right or left. One block or the other. Moving forward or falling back. It is a way of ordering the noise that surrounds us from a world whose direction we do not quite know. And this simplification has its truth, but it leaves out many things that are also at stake and which are not so simple to simplify. In this sense, it is significant that there is little or no talk about the environmental issue, given its relevance. And, conversely, it is an evident limit to everything we propose in other fields.
The Austrian economist Joseph Schumpeter described capitalism as a machine of permanent creative destruction. Capitalism destroys to recreate, and thus, by innovating, grows in the process. But things are getting complicated for us, because what we are now destroying is the physical base that makes it possible. A physical base that cannot be replaced. If we set limits on growth, the promise upon which much of politics has always functioned wavers—that is, that tomorrow we will be better off than today, and that everyone will win, even if some benefit more than others.
This promise had a concrete form of realization after 1945. Employers and workers, within each country, were able to find a formula where everyone won. It worked because capital and labor were stably linked to the same territory. Today, capital moves on a global scale, it is more financial than industrial, and labor is local and increasingly precarious. That pact according to which everyone won is unviable today. And now we need more than ever to rethink how we distribute what we can afford. But there are a few, very few, who do not need to make deals with anyone. They are outside the space of compromise.
Meanwhile, society has changed from within. It is hard for young people to see a future that improves upon their current present. A present with precarious work, impossible housing, and a planet that does not stop warming. They seek answers, and some find them in those who promise to return to a past they did not live through and that seems safer. The elderly live longer than ever, and, quite rightly, they want security and comfort. Both desires are legitimate, but they do not quite go in the same direction, and the growth prospects are not very optimistic.
The old identities that ordered politics (class, faith, the industrial neighborhood, the family) have been emptying and weakening. When the world shrinks and the future is frightening, wanting to reduce the number of those competing is the simplest and most automatic reaction. And it is here that the nation emerges as a wall and occupies the void of the other, eroded forms of social articulation. Thus, a closed “us” appears in front of a guilty “them” as a slogan that simplifies and accommodates.
All this forms a knot of intertwined problems. Housing, work, migration, energy, and climate cannot be solved separately. And the effects of each decision arrive late and unevenly. Democratic institutions were built for a simpler and slower world, where a few people decided from above with the filtered information that reached them. The more complex society becomes, the less capacity there is to understand it, and the further apart problems and solutions move. Trust in institutional politics falls, but people continue to seek and find cooperation in the neighborhood, at school, and in support networks. The problem is not that we have lost the ability to do things together, but that the connections with the institutions do not quite work, and it has not been possible to combine regulation and service production with citizen participation.
In this scenario of bewilderment and difficulty in the adaptation of democratic institutions, the reactionary and authoritarian response has a great advantage. It simplifies. It turns an opaque world into a clear narrative, with culprits by name and surname who only need to be insulted. And it offers a path back to a past that is presented as safe and welcoming for those at home. It calms anxiety, but at a high price. The price is to concentrate power, reduce the voices that respond, and delegitimize dissent. That is to say, they want to make us less capable of learning together and knowing how to adapt to the world that is transforming rapidly when we need it most. Facing complexity, their response is less democracy.
It is not easy to find answers to the great dilemmas I have just described. But indifference does not derive from this uncertainty. If we do not yet know how to get out of it, the minimum is to preserve the conditions that allow us to continue searching among us all. We must continue to defend pluralism, the freedom to debate, institutions that, with all their flaws, guarantee that disagreement is not resolved by eliminating those who think differently. There are options in these elections that do not come just to govern, but to close the space where one thinks. This is what is really being decided.
Preserving does not mean standing still. It also does not mean responding with another "us" and "them" of the opposite sign that only feeds the trench. It means protecting that which allows us to continue being, while we open new spaces where the knowledge distributed throughout society goes into the decisions. To continue promoting cities that experiment with more sustainable ways of living together, cooperatives that seek balance between work and quality of life, ways of making decisions that incorporate collective wisdom. Facing a complex world, the exit is not to simplify it, but to have institutions and ways of doing things as diverse as the society that must be governed. On November 29th we will not solve all the problems presented here schematically, but we can decide if we want to preserve the possibility of building the appropriate answers together.