Manufacturers of discomfort
I cannot get over my astonishment. ARA published a verification of the data and claims of both Pedro Sánchez and Alberto Núñez Feijóo after their face-to-face debate. The list of falsehoods and misleading information was endless.
In other words, at the moment when the two main candidates need our trust the most, do they lie to us? If they deceive us when they need our vote, what will they not do once they already have it?
Political lying is not just a lack of honesty. It has effects. The data we receive determines our perception of reality and this, in turn, determines our reactions. If a citizen constantly feels that they are getting poorer, that they are being robbed, or that the system is rigged against them, they will end up feeling indignation, even if their objective situation does not entirely coincide with this narrative.
Let's take purchasing power as an example. According to the EPA wage series and the INE price index, between 2021 and 2024 the average salary increased by 14.3%, while prices increased by 15.3%. In those three years, there was a 1% loss of purchasing power. However, if we extend the period, the result changes. In five, seven, and ten years, the average salary grew more than inflation. The minimum wage, for its part, gained purchasing power in all these terms.
Which narrative is true? It depends on the period chosen. A politician can select the three years and claim that workers are becoming impoverished. Another can choose the ten and ensure that they had never been better off. Both will use true data, but both will be deceiving us because their obligation is, precisely, to present both perspectives.
The same applies to housing. There is a very serious problem of access and supply. But it is one thing to identify the causes and another to claim that all citizens have been expelled from the market, that nothing has improved, or that a single political opponent is responsible for everything. The most dramatic data is chosen, the context is eliminated, and the exception is turned into a general category. This is called demagoguery.
This is how unrest is manufactured. Taking a real problem, exaggerating it, simplifying it, and attributing it to the adversary. Then we are surprised that there are people who take to the streets convinced that their future has been stolen from them. It is irresponsible to fuel indignation every day through manipulated information and then be shocked when that indignation overflows.
Democracy allows for disagreement regarding solutions. What we cannot allow is for our own leaders to turn objective data into throwing weapons based on lies. It is an insult to those who compile statistics and a lack of respect for the voter.