Festinomics
-
CAT -
CAST
Economics is often perceived as a gray, pessimistic, or haughty science. It should not be that way. And it does not have to be. In Kilkenny, a small medieval town in the south of Ireland, a festival that combines economics and humor with surprising success has been held for seventeen years: Kilkenomics.
The key to success does not lie only in the topics debated there. In the last edition, two weeks ago, there was talk of economic forecasts, trade wars, the rise of the far right, immigration, or the possible AI bubble. The economists who participate are the usual suspects: reference columnists from the Anglo-Saxon press, bankers from the City of London, and university professors.
What is truly differential is the uninhibited and relaxed perspective with which topics are approached. To achieve this, the debates are held in the town's small theaters and pubs, with beer taps ready, and are led by comedians. They are the only ones allowed on stage wearing a suit. Economists are asked, as a sign of respect and humility, to dress casually. It is hard for more than one, especially for those coming from the City. They do not wear suits, but they have plenty of resources to make a difference. The supposed suit of the comedians also provides material for a long conversation.
A relaxed tone does not detract from a serious and rigorous debate. In fact, it helps. The doubts that always accompany forecasts are shared naturally, and the resulting debate is richer and more interesting. Making forecasts should not be a competition to guess a figure. Everyone agrees on that. And the debate quickly delves into the different ways of quantifying uncertainty, proposing sensitivity exercises, and building risk scenarios. In the current context, this leads to an endless debate. Endless, until the comedian in charge of leading it puts everyone in order. Including the lucky banker from the City with a leather jacket, a big watch—of the kind that doesn't waste time—and flashy, pointed-toe shoes. The event concludes with thanks for the sincerity and the technical and verbal display of the panelists. And with one last question: “So, what is your forecast for next year?”.
Humor also helps to address issues that polarize easily, areas in which it is often difficult to distinguish between the legitimate defense of an ideological position and the soundness of technical arguments. Better not to mix things up. Humor helps to bring out different perceptions of reality. Everyone sees their own bubbles. And it also highlights the limitations of the metrics we have at our disposal and the policies we defend. With so many obstacles on the stage, it is clear that we economists cannot act as meteorologists or doctors: we barely agree on what the weather was like yesterday or whether the patient is sick!
Being aware of these limitations is essential to accept that there are things that cannot be fixed overnight, that many were difficult to foresee, and that those responsible are not necessarily to blame. I am sure more than one example comes to mind. And recognizing the limits is also essential so that those who have more resources understand the urgency with which many people live their day-to-day lives. A greater dose of empathy would help to better address many of the problems we have. I am sure that even more examples come to mind now.
In 2010, in the midst of the financial crisis, economist David McWilliams and producer Richard Cook thought that everyone should be able to understand what was happening without having to take a master's degree in economics or needing a dictionary to decipher the thousand and one acronyms with which we often disguise a discourse that, after all, is simpler than it seems. Seventeen years later, Kilkenny continues to fill its streets with young people, parents and children, finance professionals and groups of friends who go back and forth eager to understand what is happening to this strange and fascinating world in which we live.
I am left with the fact that economics is truly useful and interesting when it accepts its limitations, and with what Regina Rodríguez Sirvent tells us in Crispetes de Matinada: “Humor does not destroy the truth…, it makes it habitable”. After three days amidst the warmth of an old theater and a pub with carpet, chairs, and red velvet curtains, with all tickets sold out, packed to the rafters, and extraordinary comedians fueling the debates, I return with the conviction that it might be easier than it seems to reach an agreement and face the great challenges of the moment. From an Irish pub, it looks bleak, but it paints a better picture.