The difficult energy and human balance of hybrid work
Work presence directly affects sustainability on a triple level: environmental, social and economic. However, its real impact depends on aspects such as the management of daily commutes and the energy efficiency of the spaces.
-
CAT -
CAST
Over the last decade, remote work has been presented as a recipe for a double promise: personal work-life balance and a drastic reduction in emissions. Since the COVID-19 pandemic, remote work seemed like the most immediate climate action, preventing thousands of workers from crowding the access roads to large cities every morning. However, as the hybrid model has stabilized and some companies are demanding returns to the office, a complex reality has emerged. On one hand, the sustainability of corporate mobility is not just an ecological issue, but also a human and urban one. Direct contact and office presence can foster social cohesion, collaboration, and the learning of new profiles, as well as revitalize the urban fabric, local commerce, and public transport in corporate environments. On the other hand, however, rigid and forced attendance reactivates thousands of private car trips, increases stress due to traffic jams, and hinders family work-life balance.
This crossroads highlights an evident contradiction between the management's desire to have employees return to the headquarters and the need to meet emissions targets. A conflict that is directly reflected in ESG audits, the independent evaluations that measure compliance with environmental criteria. In the environmental area, these audits measure the actual carbon footprint; in the social one, they evaluate occupational health, work-life balance, and staff well-being.
The recent framework agreement between the Spanish Association of Human Resources Directors (AEDRH) and Forética, a leading business organization in sustainability in Spain, represents an explicit recognition of the fact that people management and environmental strategy cannot go their separate ways. “The sustainable transformation of companies cannot be addressed solely from an environmental or technological perspective; it must incorporate the human dimension,” explains Ricardo Trujillo, Director of Social Impact and Human Capital at Forética. Trujillo highlights that, nowadays, the major corporate challenges (such as the ecological transition, digitalization, or the transformation of business models) require close coordination between human resources and sustainability: “This is precisely the objective of the framework agreement between both entities: to foster the exchange of knowledge and best practices, promote joint initiatives, and bring the ESG agenda closer to the decision-making sphere of those responsible for people.”
The ‘commuting’ bill
Organizational decisions regarding the day-to-day operations of the workforce have a direct impact on the so-called Scope 3 of the carbon footprint, the category of the GHG Protocol (Greenhouse Gas Protocol) that accounts for all indirect emissions related to the company's activity but which are not under its direct control. More specifically, Category 7 of this protocol measures the impact of commuting (the daily commutes of employees between their home and the workplace) and the energy consumption associated with remote work.
In this sense, Trujillo warns that having an efficient corporate headquarters is no guarantee of climate immunity. “The level of maturity in this area is still uneven. Some companies have made progress in collecting data and incorporating the mobility of their employees into their emission inventories, while others continue to resort to general estimates or approximations based on average data.” For this reason, the Forética executive considers it essential to “move towards more precise measurement systems and mobility plans that allow for the identification of the main sources of emissions and to take action on them, facilitating alternatives such as public transport, active mobility, carpooling, or a more efficient organization of travel.”
Along these same lines, Eva Rimbau, a professor at the Faculty of Economics and Business at the Universitat Oberta de Catalunya (UOC) and a leading researcher in work organization, agrees that the means of transport used dismantles many assumptions about the ecological footprint. “Regarding emissions, the key is mobility: someone who travels by train every day may pollute less than someone who goes by car three days a week; these are complex calculations that depend on how teleworking is implemented in each company and how employees commute”.
This change in approach is directly driven by the new European Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD), which requires organizations to rigorously audit and report Scope 3. “European regulations force organizations to analyze their emissions more rigorously, including certain indirect impacts associated with their activity and their value chain,” recalls Trujillo. Having a corporate headquarters certified as “zero emissions” or equipped with solar panels provides reputational value, but it is unsustainable if the company daily forces employees to take private vehicles to commute to and from work.
“In labor-intensive companies, commuting represents a very significant volume of their carbon footprint,” he remarks. Incorporating the sustainability department into these organizational decisions allows for the addition of a strategic vision of great value: “It allows for the incorporation of environmental criteria into decisions that were traditionally addressed from an operational or people management perspective. I believe that other aspects in which the sustainability department can provide an interesting vision are taken into account in these decisions, such as a better understanding of employee needs and expectations, the reinforcement of the sense of belonging, or talent retention, which must weigh more and more in initiatives with a high impact on work-life balance and well-being.” From Forética, the conclusion is clear: “sustainability must be part of decision-making from the beginning, and not be limited to measuring its consequences once they have been adopted.”
Despite this relevance, the organization warns that the measurement of these emissions is still uneven across the business fabric, and that many companies continue to work with generic estimates instead of accounting for real data on distance, frequency, and means of transport used by the staff.
When working from home multiplies consumption
Nor can one fall into the simplistic view of considering that working from home is automatically 100% ecological. Here the so-called “rebound effect” appears, as the actual environmental impact of teleworking depends on how the activity is organized globally.
“Working from home can increase the needs for air conditioning, lighting, and the use of electronic equipment in homes. It may also happen that the office continues to operate at practically full capacity, even if a part of the staff works remotely, which is why a significant energy saving is not materialized,” reminds Trujillo.
A study by Cornell University and Microsoft, based on data from the United States, shows that working remotely all the time (with a 100% remote model) can reduce a worker's carbon footprint by up to 54%, but doing so just one day a week barely saves 2%.
Eva Rimbau reinforces this point: “Environmental savings become truly visible when the company takes advantage of telecommuting days to reduce or share office space. If the headquarters remains 100% open and each home is heated separately, the calculations to determine whether telecommuting reduces impact become complex”. Rimbau warns that championing telecommuting as a climate measure without reducing spaces or measuring commutes borders on greenwashing.
According to Trujillo, the goal should be to “identify which combination of in-person and remote work allows for reducing the environmental impact without shifting costs to households or deteriorating working conditions. The balance will depend on factors such as distance and the means of transport usually used, the energy efficiency of the buildings, the conditions of the homes, the number of people who telework, and the company's ability to adapt its facilities to lower occupancy”.
X-ray of real hybridization
In recent months, international press headlines have highlighted the mandatory five-day-a-week return-to-office order issued by large American multinationals. These announcements have generated a sense of a general retreat toward the pre-pandemic model.
However, official data in Spain and Catalonia show a different evolution, in which a settlement of the hybrid model is taking place. According to the 2025 Labour Force Survey (INE), 15.6% of employed people in Spain worked from home, at least occasionally, almost double that of 2019 (8.3%) and even above the peak of the pandemic in 2020 (15%).
“Teleworking has shifted towards hybrid models, with fewer days at home per person but with more people making use of it,” analyzes Eva Rimbau. “Intensive teleworking peaked in 2020 and then fell to the current 7.9%. In contrast, occasional teleworking has not stopped growing: it has gone from 3.5% in 2019 to 7.7% in 2025”.
Both academic and business analysis agree on the need to overcome the superficial debate between absolute presence and total remote work if the balance between productivity, team culture, and real sustainability is to be resolved.