In the PAU there were more requests for review for the Catalan literature exam than for the controversial mathematics one
11.7% of the students who took the mathematics test requested a review, a proportion similar to the average of the subjects, which was 10%
-
CAT -
CAST
BarcelonaThis June, alarms went off in the educational world because the lowest average grade in twelve years was obtained in the PAU mathematics exam—the university entrance exam. In the case of the scientific mathematics exam, the average was 4.18 and the students' reaction as they left the tests led teachers and families to question whether the difficulty of the test was excessive. All of this resulted in 11.7% of the students who took this exam requesting a review of their paper, and the Department of Research and Universities asking a group of 15 experts to write a report on the exam in order, if necessary, to take measures. However, while all of this was happening, up to 19.5% of Catalan literature students filed a request for a review of their exam, a proportion considerably higher than that of the students of the controversial mathematics test.
According to the response the Government has published in the Parliament's official bulletin (BOPC) and which the ARA has been able to consult, the elective of Catalan literature—mathematics is also an elective subject—is the course that received the highest proportion of review requests, followed by technical drawing (15.3%) and biology, with 15.2% of students requesting an exam review. In fact, ultimately the proportion of students who requested a review of the scientific mathematics test (11.7%) is very close to the overall average for PAU review requests this year, which was 10%, while that for Catalan literature is almost double.
Still regarding the controversy over the scientific mathematics exam, the Department of Research and Universities maintains that "the low grade" had "a uniform distribution" and, therefore, does not alter the relative position of the students in accessing their preferred degree programs. That is to say, it does not represent an individual disadvantage, as "it has affected the entire student body and will have a systemic and generalized impact." Furthermore, the department also recalls that the executive considers the results of the mathematics test to be "within the norm" and that, if the grades from the last fifteen years are taken, the grade for this summer's edition is within one standard deviation of the average.
How was the mathematics test created?
In the response given by the Government to a battery of up to 24 questions from Junts, the executive also describes how the mathematics test was developed and, in fact, the exams for all subjects. They describe how the preparation of the PAU exams "responds to a rigorous, collegiate academic procedure subjected to different levels of review" and is organized into 35 groups, one for each subject. In total, 286 professors distributed throughout the territory participate, with the presence of all Catalan public universities.
The 191 sub-coordinators of the PAU subjects send their question proposals to the person in charge of each subject; from the set of proposals, the statements that will form part of the five series that exist for each exam are selected. Subsequently, an external academic review is carried out by two or three specialists for each subject who take the test to solve it within the time allowed for the exam and assess whether it is appropriate or not.
It is in this phase that it is decided whether adjustments need to be made so that the tests have the necessary characteristics and are equivalent. All in all, 54 question reviewers are involved in the PAU: 37 university and 17 secondary school staff. "The process of drafting questions does not consist of the individual writing of an exam, but rather in academic teamwork and a culture of collaboration between the university world and high school," the Government defends in its response.