Children do not vote
Next weekend we will go to vote for those who, with luck, will govern us for the next four years. Who will define political priorities with effects that go beyond a single term, from our economic model to the guarantee of our rights. Decisions that condition the society in which we will live and also the one where the nearly eight million children who cannot yet vote will grow up.
In Catalonia, raising them costs, on average, 951 euros per month, according to the report that Save the Children has just published based on the KSNET analysis. And almost 20% of Catalan households with dependent children—about 150,000—cannot cover this cost even by dedicating their entire disposable income to it. Growing up with fewer resources than necessary means, for example, living in an apartment that is too small—17% of Catalan children live in overcrowded housing—, having less access to educational and leisure activities and, ultimately, fewer future opportunities.
This time, however, childhood has entered the campaign. From the tax cuts and birth plans of the PP and Vox to the proposals of ERC and the Broad Front, almost all parties are dedicating measures to it. Even the child-rearing benefit, which until a few years ago was mainly a demand from social organizations and the academic world, now appears in several electoral programs, including that of the PSOE.
However, not all proposals for childhood and families seek the same thing. Incentivizing birth rates, facilitating work-life balance, or reducing taxes for households with children are legitimate objectives, but they do not necessarily reduce child poverty. The PP, for example, proposes expanding the family tax allowance for income tax (IRPF). The PSOE suggests turning it into a refundable tax credit. Design matters: the first case benefits households that pay income tax, but leaves out those with lower incomes that are not required to file a return or do not pay enough tax to benefit from it. Making it refundable would allow the aid to also reach these families, precisely those that need it the most.
But design is not enough. Parties know how to make concrete promises when talking about pensions or taxes, with quantified revaluations and tax cuts. On the other hand, when we talk about child poverty, it is hard to find commitments on to what extent it is to be reduced, with what resources, and within what timeframe. And without clear objectives, we will hardly be able to demand accountability for the results. We are not starting from scratch: the European Child Guarantee, its state action plan, and the Catalan strategy against child poverty already show the way. These frameworks must be turned into government commitments with objectives, budget, and a calendar.
Children do not vote, but they will live for many more years with the consequences of what we decide. They cannot reward or punish at the polls the governments that will condition their opportunities. But we can. And four years from now we should be able to demand a clear answer: have we managed to ensure that fewer children live in poverty?