Sexual abuse, Church and presumption of innocence
-
CAT -
CAST
Oriol Xirinachs, a priest with many years of dedication to social pastoral care and head of the Secretariat for the Marginalized of the Diocese of Barcelona, author of several books, conveys to me a complaint regarding the article “A seminarian reports a priest from the Diocese of Urgell for rape”, published this past 9th and signed by Mònica Bernabé and Joan Callarissa. I extract the core of the grievance:
“As a priest, I am the most pained and desirous that justice be done in cases of abuse by members of the Church. But, sincerely and from professional criteria, I believe that when day in and day out (like today, November 10th) the newspaper publishes news of abuse in other areas, but with a much briefer note, I must see ideological intentionality in the disproportion in the two-page length and large photo of the reference case.
The fact is that these news stories about everything that can make the Church look bad are repeated often. I clearly see a contradiction here with all the proclamations of impartiality, professionalism, and truthfulness that the newspaper makes when it sets itself up as a model by comparing itself with other media. ARA is not impartial either. And without taking away even a bit of gravity, I believe that other cases published in this newspaper are more serious. I do not want to blame him more, but at 26 years old, it is not the same as the abuse of a minor. And if in the note, to save themselves, they have to use the word "alleged" so many times, couldn't they wait for a certain conviction? It is sad that today, even with newspapers, we cannot choose the best but only the least bad. Regards with the desire and hope for greater professional honesty.”
Mònica Bernabé, co-author of the report, hands me her version:
“The newspaper ARA has always made a special effort to make visible and denounce sexual abuse in all areas, not just in the Church, but also in the world of sports or culture. All the reports published on this topic are extensive because we consider it essential to provide the maximum amount of verified data that demonstrates the rigor of our reporting. An example is the investigation carried out by my colleague Albert Llimós on the alleged sexual abuse by coach Albert Benaiges at the FC Barcelona football school, or on the decades of sexual and psychological abuse by a teacher at the Aula de Teatre de Lleida, which even gave rise to the documentary El sostre groc, directed by Isabel Coixet.
When we talk about sexual abuse, we do not believe there are more or less serious cases. All are execrable, regardless of the age of the abused person. However, beyond the abuse, we also consider the cover-up to be condemnable. In the case of the Church, Pope Francis approved a motu proprio that was supposed to mark a before and an after to prevent inaction and to act "without delay" in these cases. The documentation to which we have had access regarding the case of the young seminarian allegedly raped by a priest of the Urgell diocese makes it evident that the Church still has a long way to go in this regard. All the more reason to put the informative focus on it.”
The situations reflected in the report are extremely sensitive, and the journalists who signed the article sought all possible sources, starting with verifying the alleged aggressor, who refused to give his version and hung up the phone when the journalist was about to ask for the contact of his lawyer, to whom he had referred her. Be that as it may, even though the Constitutional Court (judgment 158/2003), unlike the journalistic codes of ethics, admits that the source can be unique, the article mentions two ecclesiastical sources: the nunciature, which also chose to remain silent, and the bishopric.
It is true that the editors give validity to the complainant's version and that, often and in general, empathy with the victim can shake the presumption of innocence of the accused, in effect until there is a final sentence, as Father Xirinachs points out. However, the journalists, in addition to mentioning the presumption on two occasions, omit giving the name when they could have made it public, as has happened not long ago in a case in another Catalan diocese. According to a highly reliable source in the judiciary, the article falls within the parameters of correctness, given that “the victim gives a coherent and verifiable account and the aggressor acts with prevalence”. The bishopric must have considered it similarly, as on the same day as the publication in ARA, it removed the priest from pastoral offices and public ministry. That “the smoke of Satan has entered the Church” was not said by any journalist: it was Pope Paul VI, canonized... by Pope Francis.
In defense of reading
Complaints about invasive advertising in the digital edition are recurrent; I have dealt with them on several occasions. I note the last two emails.
On the 7th, a subscriber who asks for solutions but does not want me to publish their email makes me aware of their discomfort regarding advertising interruptions while reading on mobile, with ads overlapping the text. Three days later, I receive another email to the same effect from subscriber Josep Cañellas: “Lately when I read some articles in the digital version, ads appear that occupy part of the text and do not let me read it. It is very annoying, because the ad cannot be removed in any way. I have the latest version installed and have restarted the application, but it remains the same. I understand that it is necessary to place advertising in the newspaper, but not that it should prevent reading the text, even if only partially”.
The deputy director, Ignasi Aragay, responds to the senders after having consulted the deputy director Enric Borràs, head of digital innovation; Marc Camprodon, head of technology, and Víctor Caballé, head of advertising. This is the response to the two complaint emails:
“At the ARA newspaper we prioritize subscriptions as a source of funding, but we cannot give up any other income that helps us to have enough resources to do the free, rigorous and committed journalism that we publish, including everything from live coverage to investigative reports.
Therefore, both on the web and in the print edition, advertising appears around our news, although subscribers see significantly less of it than readers who are only registered. In any case, we must take into account that journalism, since its origin, has been financed at least in part thanks to advertising, which is a basic pillar to ensure its sustainability and, therefore, its independence.
The best way to access ARA's content –concludes Aragay– is through the newspaper's application. As some readers comment, technical issues may occasionally occur that lead to an invasive increase in advertisements. All overlaid advertising, however, should in principle be closable, and only appears to anonymous or registered users, not to subscribers. If, however, a reader has grounds for a recurring complaint, they can send a message to subscripcions@ara.cat (if possible with screenshots included) and the newspaper's technical services will analyze the incident and seek solutions”.
The function of defending the reader is also, in an essential way, a defense of reading, which those of us newspapers that maintain print versions claim with special emphasis. The relationship between print and digital editions has not yet managed to find its comfort zone. As subscribers point out, digital reading is becoming increasingly difficult, especially on mobile phones, tiny windows focusing on a few lines and obstacle courses to follow the thread of the texts with the risk of breaking the narrative rhythm. Journalism, which is a literary genre, has a duty to look after ensuring that reading is comfortable on all platforms, spending creative imagination towards coexistence with advertising that is certainly indispensable.
The Reader's Ombudsman takes note of doubts, suggestions, criticisms, and complaints regarding the newspaper's content in its digital and print editions, and ensures that the treatment of information is in accordance with codes of ethics.
To contact the Readers' Ombudsman you can send an email to eldefensor@ara.cat or record a message of no more than one minute to the WhatsApp number 653784787. In all cases, identification with full name, surnames and ID number is required.