Reading tires and thinking even more (but Rosalía's sneakers are free!)
Barcelona Pensa analyzes a widespread malaise at present: being a victim at the same time of hyperactivity and the lack of time
-
CAT -
CAST
BarcelonaWe started the week by taking the “reading is tiring” comment by the doctor of pedagogy Enric Prats out of context, and I see the move and raise it: reading is tiring and thinking is even more so. Because of that kind of masochistic pleasure one feels when racking one's brains, on Wednesday I went to one of the debates of the Barcelona Pensa festival, the series organized by the University of Barcelona. In the era of Instagrammable street biennials, it felt like an undercover philosophy class, with fifty young people (danger: young people who think!) hidden in a room at the Pati Manning.
On the table was the book Paralysis by Agitation, by the anthropologist and philosopher Lluís Aguiló (Ned Ediciones), which analyzes this widespread malaise that is the sensation of being a victim simultaneously of hyperactivity and a lack of time. “Excess agitation causes just the opposite, paralysis,” says the author—and I think of shaken babies who end up in the emergency room—. Hence why depression is a common illness of capitalism: it is the response to being subjected to the maximum power of possibilities and infinite obligations that capitalism proposes to us.” Aguiló argues that this over-agitation is not spontaneous: it is a political device for the domination of individuals, for example by turning work into a space where you not only have to perform but where you also have to fulfill yourself.His friend, former roommate, and opponent in the debate—because it seems that in philosophy, this thing about intimate enemies is popular: Socrates and Plato, Marx and Engels, Lacan and Deleuze—is the doctor of philosophy Adrià Porta. “A plant dies just as much if you water it too much as if you don't water it at all. We are that plant, we are saturated by excess,” he corroborates. For him, excess agitation also “paralyzes the capacity to imagine other decisions and the courage to undertake them.” Because elections are not a real solution: “The PP and the PSOE are similar in the most fundamental way. They are not a really different decision, there is no button to choose the economic model we want. A decision implies a loss, an election is choosing between two mayonnaises at the supermarket; whichever one you choose, in the end, you take home a mayonnaise”.
In any case, it is evident that if we find it so hard to leave capitalism, it is because it has "something extremely exciting," says Porta. There is "a secret enjoyment in our way of functioning," even if we criticize the system. "Capital does not work through repression but by generating means of satisfaction," he states, referring to that point of pleasure in pain, which if you are a journalist, you understand quickly. The book aims to position itself against this "voluntary servitude" that consumes our hours.
Conflict and clash
However, the idea that Aguiló defends is that the opposite of aspirational stress is not “stopping in the street to smell a flower,” just as the opposite of success is not wanting to fail: that would be buying into capitalist dichotomies. The author points out that the problem is that the connection to the present has been lost, and therefore, he advocates for “a presentism that is not capitalist.” When two philosophers talk about recovering the present, they are not talking about doing mindfulness and meditation, but about conflict and clash, about a general strike: “We must grieve the defeats of the past, because to act one needs a certain joy, to go light, and we must return to releasing the strength that is hidden, depressed, and tired, that does not dare to reveal itself,” says Porta.
We come out into the dark with our brains pulsing. Exerting oneself is tiring but also generates endorphins. That thing about pleasure in pain. I walk towards Plaça dels Àngels. At this point and at this hour, tomorrow Rosalía will be giving away sneakers as if she were handing out humanitarian aid. Ah, the drug of capitalism is still unbeatable.