The State Railway Safety Agency halts the transfer of the R1 line of Rodalies
Bureaucracy, the acting Spanish government and the paralysis at the Ministry of Transport make it difficult for the agreement to be closed this year
Barcelona“We continue to work on it”. This is the mantra that many of the representatives of Territory have repeated in recent months when asked about the transfer of the R1 Rodalies line, which, according to the socialist government of Salvador Illa, should arrive before the end of the year. This milestone, however, is increasingly a chimera. As ARA has learned, the folder of the transfer of the Maresme line, which opened two years ago is paralyzed on a table at the Ministry of Transport due to a problem with the line's safety certificates. The State Railway Safety Agency, which is the body that should validate it, currently cannot issue these certificates due to a bureaucratic issue.
Various railway sources consulted agree that there are two main reasons that keep the transfer stalled. On one hand, the bureaucratic one. Any track or train line needs safety certificates to operate, that is, to be able to run the trains. Since Catalonia does not have its own safety agency, it was decided during the transfer to use the Spanish one. But it turns out that the statutes of the Spanish agency do not allow it to certify the safety of a line "external" to Spain's network of general railway interest (RFIG). And, since the transfer of the R1 implies formally separating it from the Spanish network, it remains outside of any coverage.
Thus, the negotiating parties agreed months ago on a solution to the problem: changing the statutes of the Spanish agency to include a section that allows the agency to also certify its own regional lines when the autonomous community in question requests it. However, to make this change to the statutes, a chain of procedures is required that is not exactly short or simple, and which now coincides with the electoral race. At this moment, the procedures have not been started, which suffocates the calendar to manage to sign the transfer before the end of the year.
A chain of procedures (still) to be done
Before changing the statutes, it is necessary to negotiate and make an amendment to the railway sector law, have it accepted by the Ministry of Transport, have the Spanish government – currently in an acting capacity – take it to the Council of Ministers and approve it, and then, have the Congress of Deputies – in this case, the Permanent Deputation, because Congress is dissolved due to the elections – ratify it within a month. According to the sources consulted, right now the proposal for an amendment to the law remains stuck on the desk of the Ministry of Transport, “which wants to study the amendment before taking it to the Council of Ministers” and begin the entire process.
And this is, precisely, the second factor keeping the transfer of Rodalies stuck; the sources consulted point out that this entire bureaucratic ordeal is not getting started due to the lack of interlocutors at the ministry, which is more overwhelmed than ever after the accident in Urda (Toledo), with changes in the leadership, and immersed in an intense conflict with the train drivers. In fact, the same sources point out that the efforts of the newly inaugurated minister Carlos Cuerpo – after the resignation of Oscar Puente – are currently focused on these issues while, beneath him, the Secretary of State for Transport, José Antonio Santano, tries to address all fronts.
Santano's role is not easy either because in September there were also changes in the undersecretariat (the rank below him) and some sources point out that the new undersecretary is also on leave, which makes it even more complicated to have a fluid relationship between the Generalitat and the ministry.
This lack of interlocutors and the bureaucratic paralysis that derives from it is, according to railway sources, what most worries the Generalitat, which is convinced that once the necessary procedures to complete the transfer are accelerated, it will be approved without problems. However, will it be able to arrive this year, as the Illa government has strived to emphasize? “That is already more difficult,” conclude the same sources. And if there is a change of government in Spain, from the 29th, this entire process could be left even more up in the air.
The R2 and the R3, the next chapters
The R1, the Maresme line, is the oldest in the State and was chosen as the first line to begin the transfer, in January 2025, because it was precisely “the simplest.” It begins and ends within Catalan territory, which facilitated its separation from the State's general interest network. However, despite this, its secession—which runs from Molins de Rei to Maçanet-Massanes—will not be 100% complete either: the section running from La Sagrera (in Barcelona) to just the entrance of Maçanet will be transferred, leaving out of the deal some of Adif's key nodes, which are indeed considered to be of general interest, such as the Hospitalet de Llobregat station.
Despite all the initial caution and intention, the transfer of this line does not mark a smooth path, which suggests that the next lines that are at the starting gate, the R2 and the R3, will have even more added problems to complete the transfer. The R2, because it is a line with a lot of mixed traffic, of passengers and goods. The R3, because it is a line that crosses the Catalan and Spanish borders, with a final stop at La Tour-de-Carol, in Northern Catalonia, already in French territory.