Criticism from families and principals because Education will not remove screens in Preschool as it promised
The Government cannot get rid of the digital whiteboards because it acquired them with Next Generation funds and chooses to restrict their use
-
CAT -
CAST
BarcelonaThe Department of Education will not remove digital whiteboards from I3, I4, and I5 classrooms, as it announced it would do in June 2024. Ultimately, the Government has opted to restrict their use, but will not remove them from the classrooms of the youngest school children. The main reason is that these devices were acquired through Next Generation funds—during the term of Minister Cambray—which means that the Government currently lacks the authority to fully remove them or move them without risking the loss of guaranteed maintenance. In this way, as reported by El Periódico and confirmed by ARA, the Department of Education will eliminate "free use" of the screens in the second cycle of early childhood education and will not allow them to have an internet connection, but it will not remove them.
The change was made public through the update of the Responsible Digitization Plan published by the ministry, which proposes a model of "pedagogical, restricted, and safe" use. The document establishes differentiated access levels to these digital whiteboards depending on who is using them and a specific user profile, called 'Infantil' (Early Childhood), with limited functionalities and a simplified environment.
The reversal regarding the removal of the digital devices has not pleased families or school administrations, who criticize that they were not informed in advance nor were they taken into account when deciding on the usage restrictions. "We were surprised because the decision to remove them at the time was made with a group of experts, and now, suddenly, it is not being applied due to a legal issue," explains Lidón Gasull, director of the AFFAC, which represents the majority of parent associations (AFA) in Catalonia. She criticizes that although the AFFAC was part of the group of experts that decided to remove the screens, they were not informed that the measure would ultimately not go forward and would be limited to applying restrictions on their use. "Furthermore, no evidence has been provided as to why it is positive to manage it this way," Gasull insists.
On the other hand, school administrations state that the new restriction was not announced in advance and claim that "it was already evident that the digital whiteboards could not be removed". "When they installed them without consulting us about what we thought, we already saw that it was a very regulated matter, that photos had to be taken of where they were placed and that they could not be moved. It is strange that the Department of Education did not have these restrictions clear and did not know that they would not be able to remove them", asserts the president of the Axia directors' association, Jordi Satorra. Furthermore, he criticizes that it has only been a few days since they learned of the usage restrictions that the department will enforce, and this affects them when preparing classes. "We ask that if changes are made, they be done with pedagogical criteria and not just political criteria and a 'one size fits all' approach. Let the changes be made with calm reflection and knowing why and how things are done; otherwise, you just cause confusion", defends the school director.
Three levels of access
Sources from the Department of Education state that, with this new model, "the digital whiteboard should be an occasional educational resource, not a screen for permanent use." "It must be used when it adds value to shared educational activity – fostering conversation, oral language, joint observation, creativity, listening, collaborative projects, and the shared construction of knowledge – and its usage time must be controlled," they insist.
Thus, there will be three levels of access to digital devices in infant education courses: the teacher, under a password, will have full multimedia functionality; administrators will have total access to manage the whiteboard, and the classroom level will have direct access but with restrictions. Specifically, free internet browsing will not be allowed; instead, it will only be possible to access authorized resources in the EDU365 environment (interactives and workshops, for example) and the JClic activities library, which contains games to promote oral expression and comprehension, memory, or visual perception.
In addition, functionalities will also be activated to use the digital whiteboards as whiteboards – for writing with a digital marker – and as an audio player, calculator, and digital microscope, among others.