Wars and genocides in the Ottoman vacuum
How many deaths are missing to fill the void left by the Ottoman Empire? The question was asked a century ago. And it remains unanswered. The chain of wars and genocides does not stop. Nor does the desire of successive great powers to control, in whole or in part, the region where human history began—and where the subsoil accumulates almost a trillion barrels of oil—stop, as it has for millennia.
We tend to identify what was the Ottoman Empire (from the 15th to the 20th century) with what we call Turkey today and, very vaguely, the Near East or the Middle East. Looking closely, however, we find that Egypt was, until 1914, in legal terms, an Ottoman protectorate. And that Egypt, at the same time, always believed it had the right to dominate Sudan. And that the war between Sudan and South Sudan (independent since 2011), that is to say, between Muslims on one side and Christians and animists on the other, began long before the Ottomans fell. The shadow of Constantinople is immense.
Mehmet VI, the last sultan of Constantinople (today Istanbul), was deposed by the new Republic of Turkey on November 1, 1922. More than a century ago. But the embers of the great empire do not die out. Concentrated as we are on the permanent Israeli wars and the conflict between the United States and Iran (the ancient Persia, which today as yesterday wages war in Ottoman territory), we didn't even notice that last month Egypt bombed Sudanese territory. There were 72 deaths, perhaps more.
London, Paris, Moscow, and Berlin disputed the Ottoman spoils when the empire was still standing. Then the United States and the Soviet Union burst into the region. Russians, Americans, Turks, French, and British participated just recently in the Syrian civil war (2011-2025). It is the never-ending story.
It is very difficult to follow the thread of the tangle of conflicts following the Ottoman collapse. A book has just been published that is extraordinarily useful for finding one's way: The World: A Brief Introduction, by Simon Sebag Montefiore.
The author is a descendant of Sir Moses Haim Montefiore (1784-1885), the British banker (a Jew born in present-day Italy) who founded what we know as West Jerusalem, that is, the Israeli sector recognized by the UN. This may cause certain suspicions. Unjustified suspicions, in my opinion. Sebag Montefiore is one of the most brilliant, rigorous, and entertaining contemporary historians.
After the fall of the Ottoman Empire, between the First World War and the Second, the British and French empires filled the void in a colonialist death rattle. And they complicated things even further.
The end of the empire initiated a chain of genocides. The new Turkish Republic massacred the Armenians (at least one million deaths) and the Pontic Greeks (at least one million deaths). Also the Assyrians (Syriac Catholics, about 250,000 deaths). And the Druze. And the Kurds. Of course, the Greeks simultaneously massacred all the Turks within their reach. Coptic Christians in Egypt were and are persecuted. Maronite Christians in Lebanon suffered and committed massacres.
The beehive addresses a critical issue. Is Israel, like Iraq, Syria, Jordan, Lebanon, et cetera, one of the more or less artificial nations born from decolonization? Or, on the contrary, is Israel a neocolonial adventure? Sebag Montefiore leans more towards the first option.
Certainly, in a region characterized by genocidal impulses, religious fanaticism, and permanent war (more than a century without a single day of complete peace), Israel seems increasingly comparable to its neighbors.
Winter will soon begin in Gaza. The cold and humidity will complement the devastation of the Israeli bombardments while the supposed ceasefire continues. The embers of cruelty do not go out.