The national devastation
-
CAT -
CAST
In times of influencers and entertainers the PP's electoral program (The National Reconstruction) has deserved some succinct reference in the conventional media. I do not mean that a program is a contract with the voters as Lluís Llach demanded years ago, but in the case of the parties called to govern it has a practical effect which is to be the starting point for post-electoral pacts. The extremism of this program, which should make José María Aznar himself pale, denotes that it has been conceived to fit with Vox. Not in vain, the PP speaks of a model of territorial organization oriented towards functional and regulatory recentralization, the elimination of territorial asymmetries and guaranteeing the “direct presence” of the State, and Vox focuses on the rescue of competencies such as education, healthcare, security or justice, since although it maintains the traditional proposal of suppressing the autonomous communities, it has not abandoned any of these institutions and governs four of them.
To begin with, the program digs up the hatchet against the independence movement, a product of the poor digestion of the dejudicialization of the Process. The result is a great belch in the form of the recovery of the crime of sedition, the criminalization of calling illegal referendums, and the sterile repeal of the amnesty law. Other proposals are an authentic casus belli against the whole of Catalanism and advocate for an authentic national devastation: eliminating the multilingualism of the Congress or imposing Spanish in education. Far from approaches such as the “single administration” of Manuel Fraga and in the middle of the digital age, a “National Plan for the Presence of the State” is proposed to reverse the “withdrawal” of the State, although it has never left anywhere in Catalonia except from the roads since the Mossos began patrolling.
Less worrying is the proposal for competence and regulatory harmonization. Said ironically, of course. Except for the Mossos and civil law, honestly, there is nothing left to equate. The autonomic State has experienced a "silent erosion" – in the words of a document from the Basque government that analyzes the competence framework – that has left it like a plucked chicken in a process initiated with the second Aznar government (2000), followed by the financial crisis (2008) and the ruling on the Statute (2010), and clinched with the covid health crisis (2020). The recentralizing dynamic has led to an administrativization of autonomy and to Catalonia having assumed the management of the welfare state without decision-making power or financial resources.
The Constitutional Court ruling, rather than simply sending us back to square one, coagulated the autonomous State and reduced the Statute to an archaeological piece, especially in terms of powers. Exclusive powers no longer exist, under the excuse of state planning of economic activity, and shared powers leave no room for developing independent policies because state frameworks—which should be a common regulatory minimum—are stretched like chewing gum. How far away the years seem when Catalans and Basques struggled for the State to make pending transfers effective—even today, National Paradors, Imserso vacations, and maritime rescue, for example, still elude us—or to defend powers through appeals and conflicts before the Constitutional Court.
The result is that Spain has become a sort of managerial federalism: the Leviathan-State legislates everything and the governments have ministries for everything, covering areas traditionally under regional autonomy such as housing, consumer affairs, and animal protection. As I write this, I have in front of me a royal decree from last Friday regarding the identification of pets (!), which justifies state competence for economic, health, and environmental reasons. This is not the scheme that was conceived in 1978. In Germany, in exchange for the state regulating, the states (Länder) manage fully, and the judiciary and local government are decentralized and the Senate acts as a territorial chamber. That is why for some time now Catalan parties in Madrid have unfortunately resigned themselves to changing some laws so that they do not further penalize self-government or to agreeing on "singular" formulas or opt-out clauses as the Basques have done their whole lives. In short, regarding political power, we are worse off than when the 2006 Statute was created.
That is why it seems like a sick joke that the PP says that the State administration will not renounce directly exercising its exclusive competencies or that it will avoid transferring competencies in exchange for parliamentary support in areas such as the general Treasury, Social Security, defense, foreign policy or border control (measure 16), in which the autonomous regions have never had a say. Or that it will impose a single migratory authority (measures 28 and 35), since the communities can only implement social integration policies. Or that there is talk of mutual recognition of licenses and administrative simplification (measures 7, 8, 11), when a law from the Rajoy era (2013) already guarantees the unity of the market universally.