New York Times urges Spain to negotiate with Catalonia

The North American newspaper "The New York Times" published an editorial on its website on Monday, which will appear in the print edition on Tuesday, that urges Spain to seek a "political solution" to the Catalan bid for independence.

The newspaper warns that the Spanish government's "hard line" towards "Catalan nationalism" will only serve to make the independence movement "stronger, more passionate and potentially more dangerous".

The text points out the parallels between the Catalan and Scottish cases, noting that "if people are allowed an open debate and a democratic vote on self-determination, they may well choose to stay in the broader polity", while "if national ambitions are frustrated", as in the Catalan case, "they will only get stronger, more passionate and potentially more dangerous".

"A fair slice of the economic pie"

"Yet something as complex and emotional as national identity cannot be reduced to a purely legal issue; it requires political solutions. The long war with Basque separatists ended only when both sides agreed to negotiate. There is room for a political settlement here, too", the editorial stated regarding the Catalan conflict.

The leading North American paper indicated that one of the principal complaints of the Catalan population lies in the fact that they represent "16% of the Spanish population and 19% of its gross domestic product, but get only 9.5% of the national budget", and it concludes by saying that "Public opinion polls have shown that while Catalans are narrowly split on independence, a solid majority would vote to stay with Spain if they felt they were getting a fair slice of the economic pie".

_____________________________________

"New York Times" editorial, 13 October

First the Scots, Now the Catalans

The Scots and the Catalans are both ancient European cultures that became part of larger political entities centuries ago but retained distinct identities. Both are today witnessing a strong wave of nationalism and longing for self-rule. There is a major difference, however, in how this is being played out in their respective countries.

The Scottish referendum last month, like the Quebec referendums before it, demonstrated that if people are allowed an open debate and a democratic vote on self-determination, they may well choose to stay in the broader polity. Spain's hard line on Catalan nationalism demonstrates the opposite: If national ambitions are frustrated, they will only get stronger, more passionate and potentially more dangerous.

The Scottish referendum was watched closely in Spain, but from different perspectives. The Spanish prime minister, Mariano Rajoy, made no secret of his opposition to Scottish independence and suggested he would block an independent Scotland from entering the European Union. Catalan nationalists focused on the process itself as evidence that voting on self-determination is a legitimate right.

On Sept. 11, a week before the Scottish referendum and on the 300th anniversary of the fall of Barcelona in the War of the Spanish Succession, hundreds of thousands of Catalans formed a seven-mile-long "V" for "vote" in Barcelona, the regional capital. And soon after the Scottish vote, on Sept. 18, the Catalan Parliament voted overwhelmingly to formally ask Madrid for a self-determination vote to be held Nov. 9. It would ask two questions: "Do you want Catalonia to be a state?" and "if so," "Do you want Catalonia to be an independent state?"

Mr. Rajoy promptly rejected the referendum on the grounds that it would violate the "indissoluble unity" enshrined in the Spanish Constitution. Catalans argued that the vote would not be binding, and therefore not unconstitutional, but the Constitutional Court suspended the referendum pending a final ruling, which could take months.

Yet something as complex and emotional as national identity cannot be reduced to a purely legal issue; it requires political solutions. The long war with Basque separatists ended only when both sides agreed to negotiate. There is room for a political settlement here, too. A major complaint among the 7.5 million Catalans is that they represent 16 percent of the Spanish population and 19 percent of its gross domestic product, but get only 9.5 percent of the national budget. Public opinion polls have shown that while Catalans are narrowly split on independence, a solid majority would vote to stay with Spain if they felt they were getting a fair slice of the economic pie.