"Insufficient cleaning" and lack of privacy: radiography of toilets in Barcelona schools
The Ombudsman of Barcelona warns that 75% of the educational centers in the city complain about the state of the toilets
-
CAT -
CAST
BarcelonaSchool toilets in Barcelona are a pending educational space. This is the conclusion reached by the Barcelona Ombudsman after visiting various educational centers of different types in the city and consulting students, families, and teachers. In an X-ray made public this Wednesday, the institution led by David Bondia warns that in seven out of ten centers, students complain about the state of the toilets, whether due to a lack of cleanliness, privacy, or maintenance.
The report specifies that, generally speaking, both families and teachers warn that the cleaning of the toilets is insufficient. “It is not a complaint about the quality of the cleaning service, which is well valued, but rather that it is considered insufficient,” they point out. They describe how “in general” the toilets are clean first thing in the morning, but that it is necessary to “establish some type of review or reinforcement of cleaning during the day” to ensure that this cleaning is real throughout the school day. In this sense, they recall that during the Covid pandemic, this optimal level of cleaning was indeed achieved, since schools had cleaning staff available all day long.
Although the Ombudsman admits that the dirtiness may be related to “inappropriate use of the spaces” by the students because, due to their age, they have not yet consolidated their habits, he also warns that another factor is that there are toilets “with high intensity of use,” such as those used during recess or at noon, which most centers consider insufficient. “This great intensity of use means that, even with correct use, the spaces deteriorate more quickly and require more maintenance,” the report warns. Examples of the problems reported by students and teachers include dirtiness, clogged toilets, a lack of toilet paper, and bad odors.
This situation in school toilets, as explained by the family associations (AFA) consulted for the report, causes many students to avoid using the school toilet and wait until they get home. “A mother from an AFA commented, with an ironic tone, that upon leaving school they often end up using the toilet of a bakery near the center, which becomes, de facto, the reference toilet,” the analysis asserts.
Returning to student habits, the ombudsman points out that almost 70% of respondents explain that they have worked “specifically with students on the use of restrooms regarding their maintenance and cleanliness”.
The problem with the latch
Beyond hygiene, the ombudsman's report warns of privacy problems in Barcelona's school toilets, a situation that affects girls more than boys. This problem is attributed to two factors: the lack of gender segregation in toilets (75% of schools do not separate toilets between boys and girls, which "does not generate conflict") and the lack of latches on the toilets. This sometimes happens because there have simply never been latches at the school or because the toilet doors do not have any mechanism to be opened if a child gets locked inside, which is why the latches have been removed or have not been installed.
One of the reasons why privacy in toilets is a concern is menstrual hygiene, since, especially in adolescence, it "requires adequate conditions of privacy and comfort". In this regard, the report points out how many centers choose to allow girls to use the teachers' toilets as an alternative, but they warn that, although this can be a temporary solution, it is not a good long-term option because "it can generate situations of differentiation and unwanted exposure".