Pensions: the challenge of making six million more retirements sustainable
The sustainability of the system for the retirement of the ‘baby boom’ is one of the elements that is in the sights
-
CAT -
CAST
MadridThe pension system was one of the first debates to enter the 29-N election pre-campaign. And it is one of the most sensitive. Everything that has to do with these benefits affects 9.5 million people who receive some type of pension, according to the latest Social Security data. Of all of them, the majority receive retirement benefits. Political parties tend to be cautious with pensions, because they involve many potential voters –current pensioners and future ones– even though at the same time they throw promises into the air.
Now, the system faces an imminent challenge: the retirement of the baby boom generation, the most numerous –about six million people will retire in the next decade–. This translates into an increase in spending, which has put the sustainability of the system in the spotlight. Are public pensions in danger? Vox and the PP have already fueled the ghost of collapse, while Pedro Sánchez's government argues that they are not. Various experts also see it this way, and one of the main reasons is that as long as the State is willing to finance the system with social contributions, taxes, or even debt, pensions will continue to be paid.
What are we talking about?
When we talk about pensioners, one usually thinks of retirement, but these are benefits that go much further. There are two major categories: contributory and non-contributory. To receive the former, one must have contributed for a minimum period of time to Social Security. These are pensions for retirement, permanent disability, and death (received by family members of the deceased: widowhood, orphanhood, and in favor of family members). In contrast, non-contributory pensions are for those citizens who do not have sufficient resources to survive. They can also be received by people who have never contributed or have not contributed enough to receive a contributory pension.
In any case, the most numerous are retirement pensions. They are collected by a total of 6.7 million people, according to the latest data from the Social Security for the month of October, when the bill was 10.693 billion euros (74% of the total system expenditure). On average, retirement in October was 1,577 gross euros per month (in 2006 it did not reach 1,000 euros). In the case of men it is slightly higher (1,799 euros), while in the case of women it stands at 1,273 euros. The main reason is the later entry of women into the labor market, but also a wage gap that ends up affecting, later, the future pension. The average retirement of a self-employed worker is 1,063 euros per month (1,181 euros for men and 891 euros for women who have been self-employed).
In Spain, the pension system is public in nature: it is managed mainly by the State through Social Security. It operates on a pay-as-you-go system, which means that a portion of social contributions are paid by active workers and companies. At the same time, it is this contribution to Social Security that generates the worker's right to receive a pension in the future. Here, the first element that sparks debate appears: the population trend in Spain. While the largest generation will retire in the coming years, the working-age population—which must cover part of the expenditure—is smaller. For this reason, it is questioned whether income from contributions will be sufficient.
More income to face the expenditure
But it was already anticipated that this moment would arrive and that the system's cost would skyrocket – also because pensioners in Spain receive a high proportion of their last salary (it is usually the best one) and they are living longer each time due to the increase in life expectancy –. Thus, at the end of the 90s, the reserve fund popularly known as the “pension piggy bank” was created, which managed to accumulate almost 70 billion euros. This piggy bank, however, was emptied during the years of the Great Recession, when unemployment skyrocketed – there were just over 2 billion left by 2010 –. With the 2021 reform, it is being recovered: it now has 15.267 billion.
However, the 2021 reform aimed for this reserve fund not to be the only element that would help, precisely, to make the system sustainable in the face of the baby boom retirement. Other measures were deployed and, in parallel, pensioner benefits were improved after years in which they had risen very little. For example, they are now revalued with inflation, which also explains why spending has skyrocketed.
Regarding the reinforcement of Social Security revenues to be able to cover this expenditure, progress has been made in lengthening working life through incentives – the effective retirement age has gone from 64.1 years in 2016 to 65.4 currently –, in the penalization of early retirement and in the increase of contributions, especially those for high incomes. And here another element enters into dispute: equity between generations if it cannot be guaranteed that those who today sustain the system with their contributions will also receive a benefit, especially if the Social Security bill ends up being too high in the future. In fact, the Spanish government expects spending in 2050 to be 14% of GDP, a figure that the European Commission places at 16%.
Debt grows
For all these reasons, there are those who do not see it as sustainable, and, therefore, they call the model into question and look, for example, towards a mixed system with a public part and a private part (this is how parties like Vox have proposed it). They cling, among other things, to the evolution of the Social Security debt, but also to the increase in spending: in 2025, just in contributory pensions, spending reached a record of 189.598 million. This represents a 6% increase compared to 2024, but a 13% increase compared to 2023. The debt currently stands at 136.176 million euros.
As a result of the concerns raised by the system, it is being closely monitored by the European Commission. In fact, if the State deviates from the forecasts it has made in terms of revenue and expenditure, it would be pushed by Brussels to adopt new measures –which is what the current law provides for–. For the moment, the system has passed the examinations before the supervisory bodies and the Spanish government is boasting about growing revenues –which has to do with the good performance of the labor market– and a reduction in the deficit. Expenditure and debt, however, continue to grow.
-
PSC: Constitutional protection of pensions
In their electoral program, the socialists commit to a constitutional protection of pensions and their revaluation based on the CPI, focusing on “the most vulnerable,” reducing the gender gap, and protecting cancer patients.
-
Front Ampli: Above the minimum wage
The coalition led by Ada Colau defends that no pension should fall below the minimum interprofessional wage (currently €1,221/month), which will be funded through a minimum tax on large companies and a 2% tax on fortunes exceeding one million euros.
-
ERC: Safeguard purchasing power
The republicans are betting on a model that prevents the loss of purchasing power for pensioners with two central measures: pension updates shielded against inflation and taking into account territorial differences in the cost of living.
-
Junts: Catalan pensions
During the campaign, they have advocated for a pension revaluation that considers territorial differences and improvements to non-contributory pensions, ensuring their financing through independent tax collection.
-
PP: Update according to CPI
The popular party is committed to a reconstruction of the Toledo Pact with two central points: updating pensions annually according to the CPI, securing pensions for the youngest, and incentivizing active retirement with personal income tax deductions.
-
Vox: Open door to a mixed model
The far-right party proposes a capitalization system, meaning each worker accumulates their own pension. This money would be reinvested in financial markets to seek profitability (stocks, funds...).