The Prosecutor's Office appeals Alves' acquittal for review by the Supreme Court.
The TSJC had annulled the soccer player's conviction for sexual assault
The Prosecutor's Office has formally announced its intention to appeal the ruling of the High Court of Justice of Catalonia (TSJC) last Friday acquitted footballer Dani Alves by overturning his conviction for sexually assaulting a girl at the Sutton nightclub.
In this process of announcing the appeal, the Prosecutor's Office has only notified the TSJC that it will file the appeal for the Supreme Court to review its ruling, and in the coming days it will deliver the brief in which it will develop its arguments. For now, the Prosecutor's Office has only advanced the reasons on which it will base the appeal, but without specifying them. Broadly speaking, the appeal will be based on the only legal loopholes that allow it to appeal the sentence and will argue that the TSJC ruling that overturns Alves's conviction violates constitutional precepts and principles of the Penal Code.
The second time the Prosecutor's Office has appealed
The Prosecutor's Office had already appealed the first ruling in this case, which sentenced Alves to four and a half years in prison, for requesting that the High Court of Justice (TSJC) increase the sentence to nine years. However, the Catalan court rejected both the Prosecutor's Office's request and that of the private prosecution (which sought 12 years in prison) and instead upheld the defense's appeal in a ruling that resulted in the footballer's acquittal.
Although it has not yet outlined its arguments, on the one hand, the Public Prosecutor's Office will invoke the article in the Criminal Procedure Code, which stipulates that one of the grounds for an appeal is a "violation of a constitutional precept." And, on the other hand, the Prosecutor's Office will also base its arguments on another section of the same law, which in this case stipulates that an appeal may be filed when, given the facts declared proven in the judgment being appealed, "a substantive criminal provision or another legal norm of the same nature that must be violated has been violated."