Justice endorses that one can be absent from work to attend to the euthanasia of a pet
The TSJC confirms in its entirety a judgment that revoked the dismissal of a worker
-
CAT -
CAST
BarcelonaThe High Court of Justice of Catalonia (TSJC) has fully upheld a ruling that considered justified the absence of an employee who was forced to miss work due to the health status of her dog, which ultimately had to be euthanized. Now, this ruling sets a new precedent for a scenario regarding which there are few regulations and protocols: it declares the dismissal for accumulated absences as unfair and recalls that the consideration of animals as sentient beings, as well as the legal duties of care of those responsible for them, must also be taken into account when applying labor laws.
The resolution confirmed by the high court, initially issued by the labor court of Barcelona, goes beyond this specific case and proposes a new way of understanding sick leave for caring for pets. The text admits that “there is no permission or leave in the Workers' Statute” that addresses the pressing need to care for an animal in one's charge. However, the ruling concludes that this care is part of the responsibilities and obligations legally established for pet owners. All this, also taking into account the existence of “humanitarian, ethical, and moral reasons that justify prioritizing the health of a domestic animal that was practically agonizing over the obligation to attend the workplace”.
Because of all this, the TSJC considers that the employee’s absence just when they had to subject her dog to an urgent euthanasia procedure responded to a “cause of mandatory compliance, of an urgent and unforeseen nature”. This prevents it from being classified as a disciplinary offense even though neither the Workers' Statute nor the collective bargaining agreement of the company where she worked includes a specific permit for these situations.
Social change and new legislation
Beyond confirming the court's criteria, the TSJC delves into the need to interpret labor standards by attending to social and cultural change: humans no longer relate to animals in the same way we did some time ago. In this sense, the TSJC's resolution recalls that the 2023 Animal Welfare Law not only establishes the obligation to provide care to the animal but also "to maintain dignified living conditions, which guarantee their well-being, rights, and healthy development, and to provide the animal with the necessary healthcare to guarantee its health".
At the same time, the high court cites the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union, which obliges EU member states to legislate while taking into consideration the obligation to fully guarantee animal welfare. An imperative that, in the case of the State, has also been translated, among others, into the reform of the Civil Code in 2021 in order to qualify animals "no longer as mere things or movable property, but as sentient beings".
The Mossos, as recently explained by ARA, are also investigating more cases of animal abuse following the new law approved in 2023. Every day a crime against animals is registered in Catalonia.
Four absences
In the specific case of the worker, she was dismissed after having accumulated four alleged unjustified absences in one month. One of these was on November 29, 2024, when the worsening of her dog's health condition made it necessary to urgently perform euthanasia. The TSJC considers that the facts prove that the animal's state justified "the need not to delay until the end of the working day to put an end to her dog's suffering." Therefore, it rejects the company's argument that the care could have been provided outside of working hours.
"The need to avoid the suffering of an animal with whom we live has an evident emotional dimension, but also a legal dimension that the company cannot ignore when evaluating these facts," states, in this regard, Albert Vallribera, a lawyer from Col·lectiu Ronda who represented the worker. The lawyer also believes that the ruling represents a new legal paradigm, but warns that it is necessary to advance in specific regulation that provides security to workers. "The ruling justifies this absence for disciplinary purposes, but we still lack regulation that establishes how these exceptional, urgent, and proven needs should be addressed," he concludes.