In what do ERC and Podemos clash in their electoral programs?

The republicans defend the reform of the financing model and the transfer of immigration powers that the purples reject

3 min
The ERC candidate Gabriel Rufián and the Podemos candidate Irene Montero at a pre-campaign event in Madrid this Saturday.

Barcelona / MadridEsquerra reached a “collaboration” pact with Podemos that involved two conditions: that Gabriel Rufián and Irene Montero hold joint events before November 29th, and that Podemos would not run in Catalonia in exchange for the republicans incorporating candidates from the purple party into their lists. In the candidacy for Barcelona, there are two people from Podemos, and in the one for Tarragona, one. Alejandra Sandoval, who is number six for Barcelona, is the best positioned to obtain the seat if the polls of the last weeks hold true. Will Sandoval defend the financing model that ERC agreed upon with the PSC? And the transfer of immigration? ERC incorporates several issues into its electoral program that the purple party does not share and which, in fact, it does not include in its own.

The independence of Catalonia

ERC defines itself, in its electoral program, as an “independence party” that “will never renounce the freedom” of Catalonia. Podem is not pro-independence, but the common point between both formations is the defense of the right to self-determination. In fact, this is how the republican candidate, Gabriel Rufián, has claimed it in campaign events. “Negotiating the calling of a self-determination referendum in Catalonia with international accompaniment, with the European Union and the Council of Europe as facilitators,” defends Esquerra in its program for the November 29th elections.

A few days ago, in an interview on La revuelta on TVE, the Podem candidate, Irene Montero, defended Catalonia's right to decide, but reiterated that she is against Catalonia becoming independent. The “liles” (the purples) are in favor of an agreed referendum on the independence of Catalonia, but they do not incorporate it into their electoral program. They defend a “constituent process” and a vote between monarchy and republic and propose the horizon of “breaking the padlock of the 78 Regime” with a “republican constitution” that “recognizes the plurinationality” of the State. Three years ago, when the purples ran under the umbrella of Sumar, it did not appear in the electoral program. In contrast, the Broad Front this time has indeed incorporated into its program Catalonia's “right to decide.” Seven years ago, the two electoral programs of Unidas Podemos from 2019 did speak openly about an “agreed referendum”.

Regional financing

One of the key battlegrounds for ERC over the last two years has been to defend a new financing model for Catalonia. In fact, it was the turning point for the investiture of Salvador Illa. The proposal was finalized almost a year ago when the then Minister of Finance, María Jesús Montero, publicly presented the model: Catalonia would collect 4.7 billion euros more. The republicans are bringing back to their electoral program that proposal which came to nothing after Pedro Sánchez called early elections. The model that was to be approved in Congress (and which Junts opposed because they considered it insufficient) involved a reduction of what the socialists and republicans had agreed upon. In fact, ERC also incorporates into its electoral program the “solidarity economic agreement” in the same terms as defined by the republican leadership that was steered by Marta Rovira in August 2024. A model that was assimilated to the economic agreement of the Basque Country and that ERC defended by mirroring the proposal that was incorporated into the Statute in 2006 – and which was subsequently downgraded –.

All of this is incorporated into the republicans' electoral program and contradicts the position that Podem has publicly adopted. In fact, the 'purples' do not even include it in their electoral program. Irene Montero's party did not endorse the model that María Jesús Montero presented last January. At that time, the party's general secretary, Ione Belarra, linked her support for the new model to increasing the tax burden on high incomes. In fact, Belarra accused the socialists of having opened the can of worms of regional financing for “partisan interest” and to “pit territories against each other.” “It is necessary to take the money from those at the top and bring it down,” added Podem candidate Irene Montero during this campaign, ignoring that there is any problem between the resources received by the autonomous communities.

Transfer of competencies in immigration

Junts demanded that the Spanish government transfer immigration powers to Catalonia, but the agreement has not yet materialized. ERC supported this issue when it was voted on in Congress and now the republicans include it in their electoral program. "To demand the full transfer of migration and asylum powers to Catalonia to guarantee the autonomous management of reception, the assessment of needs, and integration, from a perspective of human rights and social inclusion," they argue.

Podem has opposed this transfer and, in fact, their votes against it caused the proposal agreed upon between Junts and the Spanish government to fail. In an interview with ARA, the general secretary of the 'lilac' party, Ione Belarra, argued why they did not want Catalonia to be able to manage immigration: "With immigration powers, the Mossos would conduct racist raids," she stated.

stats