TikTok and pedophilia: follow the money
It is news these days that 1,183 explicit child sexual abuse contents have been documented on TikTok, viewed nearly 48 million times. Maldita.es, author of the investigation, reported 50 videos through the platform's own channel. TikTok deleted five of them. The case is in the courts. This same month, the European Commission had already announced that it considers that TikTok violates its DSA regulations and generates with its recommendations a rabbit hole toxic effect.
Even so, no one manages to stop it. Why? Because the law treats TikTok as a bulletin board where others post things. And when someone proposes closing it, the company hides behind its 24 million users and the freedom of expression of all of them. But TikTok is not a bulletin board. It decides what you see, in what order, and how many times. And it charges for doing so.
At Xnet we have been insisting for years that it is necessary to change the approach (we explain it in the essay #FakeYou). The principle must be to follow the money (follow the money). Freedom of expression belongs to the people. Business is business and as a business it must be regulated. And it is in this distinction where we must tread carefully.
We have always opposed platforms being held responsible for the content posted by their users. Judging content, apart from flagrant cases like this one, leads to the dangerous territory of the Ministry of Truth: we are asking platforms to act as censors in exchange for continuing to prosper. It would be a grave attack on freedom of expression. Here, it is a matter of attacking the business. If the platform is a simple free bulletin board, it is not responsible for what is said on it. But if, with its algorithm to maximize results, it is the publisher, if it turns the volume up or down according to what it wants us to see, it is responsible for what we see. And its executives with it. It is the same duty of verification that we have always demanded for any actor that profits from the business of informational manipulation, be they parties, institutions, media, or corporations.
We unsuccessfully advocated for changes in the law in this regard. Now the evidence is beginning to prove us right: in June, the EU Court of Justice said that anyone who uses an algorithm to decide, in their own interest, how and with what priority content is disseminated, controls it. And whoever controls can no longer hide behind the argument of saying that they “only host.” It remains for judges to apply this to the networks.
We would go further. Platform executives should be held responsible if criminal acts such as the distribution of pedophilic material are committed on them knowing that it is such. In this case, personal responsibility does not need to be invented: it already exists. The Penal Code punishes anyone who facilitates the dissemination of child pornography and allows for the prosecution of administrators, not just the company.
The problem is not just TikTok. Meta's WhatsApp AI refused to generate images of Lula but accepted those of Flávio Bolsonaro. Bolsonarist content was flying, while Lula's campaign was hindered by the platforms. The Superior Electoral Court had to order equal treatment, with fines of half a million a day, in this case as well, with scarce real results. It is not an accident: we are talking about Meta, the same company that opened its doors to Cambridge Analytica in 2014, that allowed the spread of hate speech against the Rohingya in Myanmar in 2017, and that withdrew external verification in the United States when it suited it to get closer to Trump, along with all the other tech bosses, in 2025, just to mention the most flagrant examples of what is daily bread on Elon Musk's X
Another extreme case that reinforces our idea of follow the money is Truth Social, Trump's network. Since August, it has been selling early access to the president's messages to investors for $100,000 a month. Messages that move markets, charged by a company of which he is the main shareholder. It is pure insider trading business that violates the law by twisting the right to freedom of expression.
The arrogance of these companies can and must be stopped. On one hand, sanctions must not be just another line in the annual budget; they must involve executive responsibilities, including criminal ones. On the other, we need forceful interoperability obligations. Shutting down a network overnight punishes above all those who earn their living there or who have built their communicative capital there. Everyone should be able to take their community, their contacts, and their content elsewhere and continue talking to those who stay, just as you switch phone companies without losing your number. The day that leaving costs nothing, the threat of closure will finally be credible. The European Digital Markets Act already imposes interoperability in messaging and data portability. It just needs to be applied seriously and extended to social networks. We are not asking for anything exotic.