Why do the Government's rental data and Idealista's offers not match?
The experts endorse the data from the Generalitat and the fact that the caps are containing prices: however, if they question the measure, it is because of the negative side effects on supply and quality
-
CAT -
CAST
BarcelonaThe afternoon before the general strike for housing, on Idealista there were 130 listings for apartments in Barcelona with a rent equal to or lower than 1,140 euros, the average amount of the contracts signed in the city during the second quarter according to the Generalitat. Most of the offers were for seasonal rentals, the loophole that landlords have found in the law to avoid rent caps. Once these were removed from the equation, only 29 properties remained advertised in all of Barcelona that matched the Catalan government's estimate.
How is the difference between the Government's data and the offer on real estate portals explained? Is there one source that reflects reality and another that is mistaken? At ARA we went to look for six experts from different universities, backgrounds, and specialties, none of whom work for the Generalitat or a city council, nor do they have any economic or other interests in the real estate sector. Below, we review the bases on which they unanimously agree; starting points from which to begin discussing the approach to a crisis that already has consequences today in the political, social, and economic spheres.
What do we know about prices?
In the first place, experts agree that the data from the Generalitat, obtained from the deposits held at Incasòl, are “absolutely reliable”, in the words of the professor of civil law at Pompeu Fabra University (UPF) Josep Ferrer Riba. This does not mean, however, that there are no “problems” and things that “could be done better” regarding the information obtained, points out Université de Paris 1 Panthéon-Sorbonne professor Mariona Segú. According to her, “having data on all the contracts signed each quarter is extraordinary” in the European landscape.
In the second place, the experts also endorse the main conclusion drawn from the data extracted from the Generalitat. Ferrer Riba –like the other five specialists consulted– maintains without mincing words that “the increase in rental income has slowed down in areas where rent control operates”. The director of EsadeEcPol, Jorge Galindo, underlines that the Generalitat’s statistics are “internally consistent”, meaning that even assuming there is a distortion regarding the real price, the trend they point to is correct. The argument is simple: the fact that the origin of the data and the methodology used to interpret it are always the same means that the evolution they show over time is reliable. “The bias they have regarding the hypothetically real data is always the same,” he adds.
88% of academic studies conclude that caps have slowed the increase in rents, according to a bibliographic review that has examined publications on the issue around the world, published by the Journal of Housing Economics. “It is the only thing we know for certain regarding the issue of caps,” explains Segú. The studies do not only compare the evolution of prices with respect to previous periods, but, mainly, “how they would have risen in the absence of the caps”. “They might rise, but the important thing is that the growth where there is containment is lower than where there is not,” she summarizes.
At ARA we have compared the data from the Generalitat and those from Idealista. The former only offer the average price of new contracts signed in each municipality. In other words, we do not have the evolution of the surface area of the properties, nor the average monthly payment paid by tenants in that territory (it does not collect contracts signed previously). On the other hand, Idealista only collects the price per square meter of 24 municipalities.
To compare the data, we have equated the price from the Generalitat and Idealista in the fourth quarter of 2013, the first in which the Spanish economy grew after the economic crisis. We observe that both sources reflect the same upward price trend. There are ten municipalities where the estimates differ by 6 percentage points or less. Idealista calculates that prices have risen more than what the Government calculates in 17 municipalities. Where the difference is greatest is in l'Hospitalet de Llobregat, Tortosa, Gavà, Cambrils, Sant Pere de Ribes and Vilafranca. On the other hand, the price increase recorded by the Government is higher in five municipalities: Badalona, Terrassa, Sabadell, Rubí and Sitges. In Manresa, the difference is practically null.
What is Idealista?
Idealista is the leading real estate portal in Spain. According to the official digital consumption tracker in the country, GfK DAM, it doubles its immediate competitor, Fotocasa. Practically 1.5 million people visit Idealista every day, spending nearly half an hour on average there.
Experts ask not to generalize the content found on these portals. For example, in Barcelona, Idealista lists a total of 2,305 advertisements for a city that has more than 808,000 properties, according to the latest official data. "Portals have their own offer, but they do not represent reality," summarizes David Hernández Falagán, PhD in Architecture from the Polytechnic University of Catalonia (UPC). Beyond the numbers, the advertisements that reach the internet also suffer from other biases that make them impossible to extrapolate to the market as a whole. Which apartments end up posted on the internet?
Duration and prices
First of all, Hernández Falagán brings up the possibility that “long-term supply might not even reach the portals”. High demand for housing means that, on one hand, real estate agencies place the apartments they receive among the clients they have on a waiting list before publishing them on the internet, where they may never even get advertised. On the other hand, part of the available apartments are assigned through word-of-mouth. Recently, ARA published an interview with Matthew O. Jackson, a professor at the prestigious Stanford University, where he stated that “your friends' parents are one of the most determining factors in your professional trajectory.” To what extent does the same apply when it comes to finding a place to live?
“In an environment of low trust and high uncertainty, it makes a lot of sense that the person offering the apartment wants to rent it out through word-of-mouth,” reflects Galindo. In this vein, Segú predicts that “in alternative channels, prices are lower,” because they involve less management work and the trust and security derived from a shared social network come into play.
Secondly, seasonal rentals are overrepresented there. For example, according to Hernández Falagán, “3 out of 4 ads [on Idealista] in Barcelona are for short-term rentals,” yet they represent 15.6% of the contracts signed in the city during the second quarter of 2024 (at least of the deposits that have been lodged with Incasòl, as legally established).
Finally, thirdly, Montserrat Pareja-Eastaway, a researcher and professor of applied economics at the University of Barcelona (UB), warns that “the asking prices are one thing, and the price at which the agreement is finally closed is something very different.” Idealista reflects the former, and Incasòl the latter. Fotocasa Research (the study team of the real estate portal Fotocasa) estimates in a study published this October that in the last year, 27% of tenants have negotiated the agreement, and 57% have obtained some discount.
Is there a clear assessment of the caps?
Prices are only one of the effects that rent control has on the housing market. In the academic world, there is a consensus that the measure has negative consequences—externalities, in economic language—. "You don't just have to take into account the prices, but also the duration of the contracts, the location where they are made, the conditions of the apartments…", lists Pareja-Eastaway. Although experts confirm the reliability of the Government's data –they are, and the caps have contained prices–, this does not imply that they endorse rent control as a measure to solve the housing crisis. There is no official and generalized data on the effects it has on the housing supply and the quality of the stock.
On the one hand, the balance of new contracts –that is, the difference between those that have been signed and those that have expired– has been gradually reducing since the entry into force of the caps. Even so, Catalonia has more rented apartments than ever: 827,456 properties, compared to the almost 804,000 that there were before the implementation of the measure. However, we do not know if landlords are deliberately withdrawing apartments from the rental market because the returns are insufficient or if the reduction in new contracts responds to the fact that families are extending their stays. In this case, the properties do not return to the market. The figure for new contracts does not include renewals because landlords do not return to deposit the security deposit.
On the other hand, the containment of new rents does not necessarily imply a reduction in the price per square meter. Barcelona is the paradigmatic example: although, according to the Generalitat, this second quarter new contracts set rents 4.4% lower than before the entry into force of the caps, the price per square meter is higher than ever. Once again, what we do not know comes into play: are the apartments currently available in the Catalan capital smaller because the large ones have been removed from the market, or because the families living in them are staying? How much would prices have risen without the caps?
Data can support anything
Beyond the concrete effects of a measure on the market, experts insist on the importance of having exhaustive data that allows for an in-depth analysis of the market and an evaluation of the effects of public policies. The professor of administrative law at the University of Barcelona (UB) Juli Ponce recalls –with a certain irony– that the right to housing law has “a much more boring chapter, which few people talk about, regarding the need for public administrations to generate information”. He stresses that historically they have not done so, although recently several observatories have emerged.
From Esade, Galindo suggests that an express statistical operation should be promoted, “well done, as only statistical institutes know how to do”. A kind of equivalent to the Active Population Survey (EPA) for the housing market. “We have data with limitations, we are making public policies and pushing for caps without good data”, he concludes.