The TSJC will decide on the teleworking of the senior officials of the Generalitat
The courts have issued contradictory sentences regarding this case
-
CAT -
CAST
BarcelonaThe Administrative Litigation Chamber of the High Court of Justice of Catalonia will have to decide on teleworking for high-ranking officials of the Generalitat, after courts have issued contradictory rulings on this matter. An administrative litigation court in Barcelona has annulled the ban on teleworking for deputy directors of the Generalitat's Department of Business, in the opposite sense to another ruling that endorsed it for officials of the Department of Economy, for which reason it will be the High Court of Justice of Catalonia (TSJC) that will settle the matter.
In the second ruling, to which ARA has had access, the number 7 seat of the administrative litigation court of the Barcelona Instance Court upholds the appeal of seven officials from the Department of Business and Labor, represented by lawyer Benet Salellas, and annuls the instruction that prohibited them from teleworking, understanding that it violates a provision of a higher rank. The judge argues that the instruction that forces the deputy directors of the Generalitat into mandatory in-person work contradicts the 2020 decree that established that teleworking is applicable to personnel in the service of the Catalan administration and its autonomous bodies.
For the judge, the instruction “clearly modifies” the regulation of teleworking for Generalitat personnel and “innovates in the legal system,” given that it eliminates it “absolutely” for deputy directors general and positions organically assimilated to this category, reports Efe. In other words, it establishes an exception to teleworking not provided for by Decree 77/2020, adds the ruling, which consequently concludes that the Government's instruction “is null and void for violating what is provided for in an administrative provision of higher rank.”
Taking into account the “normative character” of the instruction, however, the judge considers that they do not have the authority to declare the nullity of the provision, which is why it opens the door to raising a question of illegality that will have to be resolved by the High Court of Justice of Catalonia (TSJC). The high Catalan court will be the one that, in the final instance, decides on the veto on teleworking for deputy directors general and establishes a single criterion, given the disparity of resolutions depending on the court in which the case falls.
In fact, in another ruling in the opposite direction, made known this Monday, the 14th court of the contentious-administrative chamber of the Barcelona Instance Court upheld the veto on teleworking for deputy directors, understanding that the Government can require them to perform their work in person due to the responsibilities and functions they have assigned. In this ruling, the judge dismissed the appeal filed by a group of 21 officials against the Department of Economy and Finance, considering that the Government can "require continuous physical presence" from these civil servants, the last tier of the administration before political appointees.
"The teleworking modality is not configured as a subjective right of the personnel, but as an alternative in the organization of work as a discretionary power of the administration," this ruling notes.
At the time, the Ministry of the Presidency, led by Albert Dalmau, maintained that working remotely was "hardly compatible with the nature and responsibilities inherent" to the position of deputy director general, due to their "high degree of strategic responsibility" and their role in coordinating teams. The decision was made effective in an instruction on January 7, 2025 and also affected positions assimilated to deputy directors general. At that moment, around a hundred of these senior executives of the Generalitat had requested authorization to work a maximum of two days remotely.